Leadership Presence: How Do You Feel About This?


Leadership Presence


Carol Kinsey Goman, Ph.D.

If you asked Bella, the miniature Australian Shepard in this photo, she’d tell you what a great time she’s having rolling in the mud! But if all you had to go on was your personal reaction to this image, you might have come to a different conclusion.

Bill Toppeta, a former executive officer of MetLife, Inc., once told the Fordham Leadership Forum, “What you need to know as the leader is what motivates your people, not what motivates you.”

To bring this philosophy into reality, here is the simple, yet revealing exercise Toppeta used: He would distribute a questionnaire to managers and their direct reports. The managers ranked the items on the page in the order of what they believed most and least motivated their direct reports. At the same time, the direct reports also ranked the items on the list. The lists were compared and then a discussion began that looked at the results.

Toppeta said that, for the most part, managers did horribly on this exercise. They thought they knew what their people were passionate about — but they were wrong.

When we talk today about showing empathetic leadership and creating psychological safety, we sometimes forget to ask the very people we are trying to influence questions like: “What’s your point of view?” “What makes you feel valued and safe?” “What motivates you?” “What’s working and not working for you right now?”

Another way to think about this is to apply The Platinum Rule. As you know, The Golden Rule is to “Treat others as you wish to be treated.” The Platinum Rule is “Treat others the way they wish to be treated.” The Platinum Rule requires a deeper connection with and attention to the other person’s preferences, motivations and emotions.

But don’t simply guess what that emotional state is – or use what motivates you as a standard for all. Begin by asking – and listening closely to the answers.

5 Body Language Hacks that Make You Look Like a LeaderAbout the Author:  Carol’s passion for showing audiences how to develop the verbal and nonverbal habits of leadership presence, has helped thousands of leaders in 32 countries reach their next-level career goals. She is an international keynote speaker and seminar leader, executive coach, creator of LinkedIn Learning’s best-selling video courses, Body Language for Leaders and Collaborative Leadership, and author of the award-winning book, STAND OUT: How to Build Your Leadership Presence. To book Carol to speak at your next in-person or virtual event, contact her at Carol: Carol@CarolKinseyGoman.com or through her website: https://CarolKinseyGoman.com